Minolta AF 50mm F1.7 A-mount lens review by Phil Wood
|Phil Wood#44187 date: Dec-11-2018|
flare control: 4
|ownership:||I own this lens|
|compared to:||Minolta 50mm f2.8 macro|
Minolta 50mm f3.5 macro
Sony 50mm f1.8 DT
Sony 35mm f1.8 DT
Sony 85mm f2.8
|price paid:||30 GBP|
|positive:||Build quality, size, price, wide aperture, focal length on FF.|
|negative:||My copy has back focus, only f1.7.|
|comment:||When I bought this lens I was disappointed, it wasn't much sharper than the kit zoom (18-70). Since acquiring cameras with microfocus adjust I have discovered the problem to be a back focus issue. With adjustments the lens is impressively sharp once stopped down a couple of stops. |
Wide open the centre is sharp - which is what you need in most cases, corner sharpness doesn't matter if your aim is to blur the background.
In comparison with the two macro 50mms it's advantages are price, size, the wider aperture and marginally better focusing. The macros are significantly sharper, focus closer (much closer) and have better contrast - and they aren't much more expensive. If the wide aperture is of interest (and it should be) then there are the Minolta f1.4 and its Sony reincarnation (which I don't have experience of) and the Sony f1.8 DT. This latter lens is APS-C only and only out performs the f1.7 in terms of flare control - but the 1.7 is not bad in this respect, I honestly don't see a good reason to buy the Sony in preference to a well-adjusted copy of the 1.7 (unlike mine). To be honest the Sony is the least successful A-mount prime I've experienced - partly because of the comparison with the cheaper, better built, better performing 1.7.
The other issue is that 50mm is not the most useful prime on an APS-C body, I'd opt first for the excellent 35mm f1.8 DT, which offers the equivalent 'standard' lens angle of view on APS-C. The 1.7 works as a good short portrait lens, but the other great low cost Sony prime, the 85mm f2.8, is even better (and works as a short portrait on full frame). However, f1.7s are available for under 50GBP and you won't get a much better lens for that sort of cash.
If you own a full frame A-mount body you probably already have one of these lenses or an f1.4, if you haven't then you may well not own a prime of any length. I recommend you get one ASAP! The discipline of shooting with primes is well worth experiencing (and you can join Dyxum’s Week 50 Challenge).
UPDATE I have recently completed the week 50 challenge. I set out with the intention of sharing the week between all my 50nms - but the two that spent most time on my A900 were the f2.8 macro (I love that lens) and the f1.7. I have to say that I like it a lot more than I did at the start of the week, it really is a very good lens.