Sony AF DT 18-55mm F3.5-5.6 SAM II A-mount lens review by QuietOC
|QuietOC#15271 date: Jun-11-2015|
flare control: 4
|ownership:||I own this lens|
|compared to:||Sony E 16-50 PZ OSS|
Sony DT 16-50 SSM
Sony DT 16-80 CZ
Sony DT 16-105
Sony DT 18-55 SAM
Sony E 18-55 OSS
Sony DT 18-70
Sony DT 18-135 SAM
Sony DT 18-200
Minolta AF 24-50 F4
Minolta AF 24-85 & RS
Minolta AF 24-105 D
Minolta AF 28-80 D
Minolta AF 28-85
Minolta AF 28-100 D
Minolta AF 28-105 & RS
Sigma AF 28-105 F2.8-4
Tamron SP 17-50 F2.8
Tamron AF 18-250 F3.5-6.3
|price paid:||Included with A68|
|positive:||Good image quality|
Zoom and focus controls are smooth
Little sample variation
|negative:||Minor focus shifting from slop in the zoom mechanism|
Problems on the wide end:
-Significant barrel distortion
-Heavy purple fringing
|comment:||The first copy was included with my new SLT-A58K. I won a second used copy for $8 on eBay. The focal length encoder on this second copy was broken but easily fixed. The third copy was purchased used in like-new condition from a large seller. The fourth copy was included with my factory refurbished ILCA-A68K. "Made in Thailand"|
This lens has identical optical performance to the older version, but the focus and zoom mechanisms are smoother. This version more closely resembles the 55-300 and 18-135 lenses, while the older version looks similar to the Easy Choice primes and last Konica-Minolta kits with the shiny chrome accent ring.
I like the size, weight and operation of this lens. It actually performs quite well and in some ways better than the $1000 Carl Zeiss. I've mostly avoided using it especially after purchasing the 35 mm prime It also compares well with the 20/2.8, 24/2.8, and 28/2.8 primes as far as image quality. Besides the SAM motor, the design operates similar to the older Minolta kits lenses. The SAM avoids the weak plastic AF gears which often fails in those older kit lenses.
The controls are quite nice to operate especially compared to the overly loose, cheap feeling focus rings on the Easy Choice primes. They certainly operate smoother than those on older SAM version. There is a noticeable amount of hysteresis in the zoom mechanism. The lens is quite parfocal except for that bit of play in the zoom mechanism which results in a small focus shift when changing zoom directions. If you move the zoom control in just one direction the focus is well maintained.
Aberrations are well controlled at the long end of the zoom range. Corners are sharp at 55 mm with very little purple fringing.
The 18-55 has substantial image quality improvements over the older 18-70 on the long end. It has a bit less raw distortion than the older 18-70 kit lens, and the distortion is well corrected by the in-camera compensation. It has less distortion at 24 mm and above than the other zoom lenses.
The small ALC-SH108 hood was not included neither was a proper rear cap. This hood is identical to the SH0006 hood of the 18-70 and to the those from the plastic Minolta 28-xx zooms. The filter threads rotate during focusing (but not during zoom operation) so a larger petal hood will not work. The hood is so wide and shallow it is probably useless for anything other than protecting the front element. It does greatly improve the appearance of the lens.
Image quality seems to be well corrected for the long end of its range which is good for macro or portraiture. The older 18-70 is mostly inferior though that lens does not suffer from focus shift at 18 mm when stopping down. The larger 18-135 SAM has more center sharpness. The E mount 18-55 OSS has more consistent center sharpness.
This lens actually covers full-frame over much of its focal range and has decent image quality.
Overall a very good kit lens that is worth the small premium when it is included with a new body purchase. It does a bit of everything pretty well. The significant change in the II version is the smoothness of the zoom and focus mechanisms along with the obvious cosmetic changes. Recommended.